Amid all of this great fanfare and entertaining, well, fare, there of course were some bad titles. However, instead of focusing on the ones that are doomed to be forgotten (hello The Banished Former Hero Lives As He Pleases!), I want to highlight the projects that left an indelible impression last year for all the wrong reasons. 2024 started with many critics and viewers thoroughly impressed with the first episode of Metallic Rouge, with some going so far as to call it best of the year material. Then the rest of the series transpired and it steadily lost its luster and all of its goodwill, with many anime fans lamenting the pacing and numerous story issues. Speaking of losing their goodwill, former Crunchyroll Original and 2020 big hit Tower Of God became a total laughingstock with its elongated and much hated second season. That may have been pretty bad, to the point where it seemed you couldn't go anywhere without someone lambasting it, but it wasn't as near universal as the poor reception for the fourth season of Demon Slayer: Kimetsu No Yaiba. This season could be summed up with one word: Boring. I'm still not caught up with the show to totally confirm this assessment but considering my opinion of the To The Hashira Training movie last year, I can totally believe it. And despite harsh critical reception and being a presence on many worst of the year lists, the edgy isekai Failure Frame was a popular hit with many and a true guilty pleasure for some but was no Arifureta.
One of the biggest negatives of Failure Frame was its fluctuating animation quality, a complaint that proved to be a very notable issue in other shows but for a few, it became the death blow. Shonen soccer drama Blue Lock ramped up the stacks for season two but you wouldn't have felt it because the sports action was practically a slideshow, largely thanks to alleged poor production conditions and decision making. Whisper Me A Love Song became a bizarre affair because of similar production issues as the yuri romance was scheduled for January, delayed to April, aired its first ten episodes until the end of June, then ghosted until December 29 when the final two episodes aired. But there were two that took the cake of infamy last year. First up was Our Last Crusade Or The Rise Of A New World, whose second season was greenlit back in 2021 but by the time it premiered last July, only four episodes were made. It was quickly announced that all future episodes were delayed indefinitely in order "to maintain the quality" of the show, with no word since of any progress or cancellation. And then, there was Uzumaki. Dear lord, Uzumaki. The television adaptation of the beloved manga from horror maestro Junji Ito was heavily hyped up for several years, had the backing of both Production I.G. and Adult Swim, and looked to finally deliver what Ito fans wanted. The first episode aired to utter rave reviews due to its breathtaking animation, haunting black and white art style, and faithfulness to the original story. Then episode two aired and everything quickly went to shit. The animation was now completely poor and horribly executed. Clips were quickly shared online and memeified, the show started to negatively trend on social networks, and its issues were becoming more widely noted by mainstream outlets. Nothing improved with the third and fourth episodes and the miniseries would become the biggest fiasco of the year.
Those were some pretty bad shows but there were worst things happening in the news front of anime. The biggest news story for all American anime fans was the official closure of Funimation. The distributor/streaming service fully merged with its Sony compatriot Crunchyroll in April, with users given the option to unite their accounts and watch history. However, there were two very big problems, one of which drew the most ire. Not only were a great amount of Funimation shows not coming to Crunchyroll, including anime classics like Crest/Banner of the Stars and Escaflowne, but user's digital copies of anime shows, which came with the purchase of Funimation blu-rays, would be nontransferable. Myself and a ton of others were rightfully furious at the latter issue, to the point that it made mainstream business news. The president of Crunchyroll would later state that they are looking to compensate users for the digital copies but nothing has been heard of the action since. Crunchyroll would further draw anger when in July the streaming service removed all fan reviews and episode comments, as in the entire history of them since the service's inception. This decision apparently was brought on due to an online hate campaign and review bombing of the new yaoi romance show Twilight Out Of Focus but others also point out that it coincided with the negative reception to the poor subtitling of another new show My Deer Friend Nokotan, allegedly due to it being A.I. generated and an attempt for Crunchyroll to justify cutting costs and reducing staff.
When it comes to poorly received dubs, however, Crunchyroll had nothing to do with that last year. Instead, it came from the near mishandling of the American blu-ray release of Lovely Complex. The popular 2007 romcom was finally coming to blu-ray via Discotek Media and it was also announced to be getting a new English dub. However, the release became product non grata when one of the dub writers, Brendan Blaber aka YouTuber JelloApocalypse, opened his smug mouth and stated in an online post that he hated the show and how he helped "fix" it by changing a lot of its original elements. Apparently, Discotek noticed the changes and removed them in the nick of time, right before they and everyone else in the anime distribution, translation and localization industry blackballed Blaber from all future projects. But the biggest declaration of blackballing actually came from Japan, when legendary voice actor Toru Furuya, the man who was the voice behind Amuro Ray, Tuxedo Mask, Seiya, and Sabo, self-imploded his own career after a damning interview in late May. Furuya shockingly admitted to previously having a 4 1/2 year long affair with a fan, where he physically and mentally abused her and disturbingly forced her to have an abortion. A month later, when the outrage refused to go away and companies began to pull him from current and future projects, the actor announced that he would be stepping down from his talent agency and from all of his famous roles. One anime production company that also didn't have any future projects and didn't survive to the end of 2024 was Gainax, the legendary animation studio that gave us Gunbuster, Neon Genesis Evangelion, and Gurren Lagann. After more than a decade of controversy, poor business decisions and creative exodus, the studio declared bankruptcy and ceased operations in June.
While there were a lot of bad things that happened in the anime industry last year, nothing was as worse as when we lost several people that helped shaped it. Noriko Ohara and Atusko Tanaka were two of the greatest voice actresses ever, giving life to such famous characters as Nobita Nobi and Mokoto Kusanagi respectively. Hinako Ashihara was a popular shojo manga artist that just wanted her work to be faithfully adapted by others. Rachel Lillis was one of the American queens of anime voice acting from the late 90s to mid-2000s, being the original and signature voice behind the tomboy gym leader turned Ash's traveling buddy Misty, Team Rocket villainess Jesse, and the ever troublesome singing creature Jigglypuff in the Pokemon franchise. She also became a hero for many girls and/or those looking for a strong character that matched their sexuality when she voiced the titular character/queer icon of Revolutionary Girl Utena. And then, there's Akira Toriyama. The man who created Dragon Ball, the title that changed the medium of manga and the shonen genre. The man who created Dragon Ball Z, the title that was so revolutionary and different for the American public that they were able to accept this thing called anime. The man who co-created Dragon Quest, the video game franchise that became an institution of the role-playing genre and a true cultural phenomenon in Japan were it not for his contributions as character and monster designer.
I wanted to get all of the good, bad, and really heavy stuff out of the way first because, well, there was a lot of it in 2024 and they were far more important than the so-called plights facing this anime viewer. I only watched a little more than I did last year but I didn't feel like I squandered anything besides not paying for one last month of Funimation before it was wiped from online existence. I really had a hankering to watch Crest of the Stars again and to finish up Chrome Shelled Regios but not so much as to go and buy them on DVD. I of course also didn't hit any of my goals, with the one I'm really angry at myself for not doing was watching and cheering on the second season of Bottom-Tier Character Tomozaki-kun. Despite getting really good reviews, the show seemed to have suffered the same audience apathy that befalls all second seasons of anime shows. But the thing that really pissed me off, more so than the Funimation digital copies issue strangely, came in August when iTunes suddenly without explanation ended its $4.99 anime sales. For a long time now, an anime fan could biweekly get a 13 to 26 series/season digitally and spend only five bucks, whether it was one of their favorites or a title that looked interesting or simply to grow their digital library. And this just ended late last year with no announcement why, leaving myself and many others truly dismayed. Seriously, there are a lot of Americans that don't want to support Crunchyroll or Sony but would gladly give up a Lincoln to Apple. Whatever or whoever was responsible for the demise of the sales, Apple certainly suffered the consequences of the action, as their anime television sales have dropped significantly on iTunes according to their daily top charts.
Now let's just get on to the main event, shall we? Here are the list of anime shows that I watched last year. As always, the list goes from what I dubbed was the best all the way down to the least liked or worst. The rules are the same: The overall quality of the show and my response to it are the major factors toward their rank. However, other additional factors such as replayability, voice talent, and lasting impact can help sway their placing. Only new shows/new viewings count; rewatches are immediately disqualified and if I watch a show that I already started, only the continuing unwatched episodes will be reviewed. I treat and grade all series fairly, even ones that I haven't actually finished or may not choose to finish. If you see a * next to the title, that means I had a limited sampling of the show or didn't complete the series/franchise fully.
1. The Wrong Way To Use Healing Magic
Next time somebody says that there isn't any good isekai shows around, point them to this one. This series gives us a really likeable mc, an awesome twist on "healing" magic, characters that we actually care about, a lot of great action and comedy, and a fantastic English dub. Seriously, my favorite quote of the year was Alexis Tipton's delivery of the line, "Look at all of this BEEF!". And once, RIP Atusko Tanaka. Colleen Clinkenbeard may have pulled off her usual badassery as the hardnosed, hardcore healing mage Rose but Tanaka brought the goods, especially the comically maniacal side of the character.
2. My Happy Marriage* [eps. 1-8]
Oh, I just love a good melodrama when it is pulled off well. With this show, you get six excellent episodes and a fantastic climax only to go, oh wait, there are another six episodes left. Unfortunately, I fell off with the next storyline, mainly because of that stupid boring interloper, but I do plan on catching up with the show so I can watch the second season, which has currently started on Netflix. This show also gets bonus points because I actually got my mom interested in watching it.
3. Chillin’ In Another World With Level 2 Super Cheat Powers
Yep, another isekai but with a slight twist. I frankly just enjoyed how this show spent a lot of time on the main couple and their ever evolving relationship, to the point where holy crap the main characters actually had sex! Also, the protagonists' first encounter with the djinn character was one of the best anime moments of the year. It did have some notable issues though specifically how the other summoned so-called hero just becomes a gag character despite his evil actions and how the Demon Lord's ordinary form doesn't make him good looking at all. Still, the show was straight up funny and I had a good time with it.
4. The Ossan Newbie Adventurer, Trained To Death By The Most Powerful Party, Became Invincible
One of the sleeper hits of 2024, this had a lot more to it than just a goofy premise and hot dark elf girl. It has a great message about how even when the world gets you down and says you can't, holding on to your dream and pursuing it any way you can will always be a just cause. Yeah, I'm reading a little too much into something that basically presents what if Izuku Midoriya lived in a fantasy world and was in his 30s but the show was still a nice surprise treat to enjoy. Lastly, having the opening tune be a throwback to old hero anime theme songs was the perfect cherry on top.
5. Fairy Tail* [eps. 87-118]
Finally cleared the Edolas arc, only to get stuck in the Tenrou Island arc. I swear I'll eventually "all clear" this series simply so I can finally play the franchise's recent JRPGS. Also, "Soul of Iron"/"Iron Soul" is a great watch.
6. Let This Grieving Soul Retire
I loved how this series played with standard fantasy tropes and its satirization of so-called heroic adventurers and the fearless mastermind who oversees them. Unfortunately, the show slugs a bit in the middle episodes, especially since the action is literally taking place at the same dungeon from the first storyline but now with more forests. Still, it gets by with its humor, creative touches to its opening credits and ending previews, and great performances from Kensho Ono and Fairouz Ai.
7. Hokkaido Gals Are Super Adorable!* [eps. 1-10]
This was the first anime I watched last year and I had a lot of cozy fun with it, even with all of the blatant "come to Hokkaido" story elements. My only guess as to why I didn't finish it was probably because I didn't like how the protagonist's grandma suddenly turned heel and actual stakes were thrust into the story. I'll try to get around to finishing it, or at least re-watch the Valentine's Day episode, which I felt was the best of the series.
8. In Another World With My Smartphone 2* [eps. 2-4]
Yep, I'm still chugging through this second season, even though it is not as great or fun as the first. After seeing three more episodes, I can now safely say that man, what a terrible first episode this season had! It needed to spend less time staring at all of the heroines' bras and breasts and more time on the comedy and interpersonal relationships. No wonder I gave this up in 2023.
9. Ladies Versus Butlers [eps. 1-7]
I would love to say that fan service shows aren't always that bad but then I watched this one. It has its moments and the dub is okay given that it's coming from Media Blasters. However, to paraphrase the great Crow T. Robot, this is a good display of when sexy becomes annoying. And come the fuck on with that female artist character and how she is totally "19" years old.
So, what do I have geared up to do this year? First, I want to dabble with HIDIVE and their selection of shows, especially since Amazon did another one of their special subscription sales through Prime Video. I want to finally give two big Funimation titles a watch, those being Classroom of the Elite and High School DxD (yes, I will be watching the dub despite you know what). I want to catch up with Fire Force, especially before the final season starts later this year. I also want to catch up with my beloved Iruma-kun before season 4 comes about. And finally, I want to finish up the second season of My Next Life As A Villainess, which I have putting off for three years now!